Liam Duckstein
Manchester City might just have the upper hand in the race to sign one of England’s most promising young defenders, Jarrad Branthwaite — and it’s thanks to a familiar face: John Stones.
With the summer transfer window fast approaching, Everton are reportedly planning to “sound out” a deal to bring Stones back to Goodison Park. The England international, who made a name for himself on Merseyside before joining City for £50 million in 2016, endured a challenging 2024-25 season marked by injuries and limited playing time.
Stones’ Struggles Open Door for Exit
The 31-year-old defender managed just 20 appearances across all competitions last season, missing the final three months due to a hamstring injury and earlier stints out with foot problems. With only 11 Premier League appearances—just six as a starter—Stones has seen his influence at City wane significantly.
As he enters the final year of his contract, City’s willingness to listen to offers suggests a parting of ways could be imminent. While Pep Guardiola still values Stones’ exceptional ball-playing skills, concerns about his durability loom large in City’s long-term planning.
Everton’s Interest Sparks Branthwaite Speculation
Everton’s pursuit of Stones isn’t just about nostalgia or leadership—it could be tactical. Branthwaite, their highly-rated centre-back and a rising star in England’s defensive ranks, has drawn interest from Chelsea, Manchester United, and now Manchester City.
Valued at around £70 million, Branthwaite won’t come cheap. But if Stones is included in a potential part-exchange deal, City could significantly reduce the upfront cost. Given his history with the club and desire for more minutes ahead of the 2026 World Cup, the move makes sense for all parties.
The Bigger Picture: City’s Defensive Evolution
With young talents like Abdukodir Khusanov, Vitor Reis, and Juma Bah emerging, City are clearly planning for the future. Swapping out a veteran like Stones for a next-generation defender like Branthwaite aligns with that vision—and keeps them competitive across all fronts.
Time is of the essence. Clubs have until June 10 to make pre-Club World Cup signings, after which the window reopens on June 16 and closes on September 1. If this swap is going to happen, the groundwork must be laid soon.
Verdict: If Manchester City play their cards right, John Stones could be more than just a departing player—he might be the trump card in one of the summer’s most intriguing transfers.