Alex MacQuoid
| Prefer us on Google — see Tips.gg in Top Stories & Discover | Add on Google |
The Edinburgh derby is always a different beast. Hibernian host Hearts at Easter Road on September 3rd in what is shaping up to be one of the more evenly matched early-season meetings between these two clubs in recent memory. Both sides sit on 6 points from 3 games, though Hearts carry a notably better goal difference at +4 against Hibernian’s +1. What makes this particular fixture interesting is the European hangover factor: both clubs have been active in continental qualifying this summer, and the cumulative fatigue from those midweek commitments could play a real role in how this Edinburgh clash unfolds.
Two players worth watching closely here. For Hearts, Calvin Miller has been quietly exceptional in the last five matches, contributing 3 goals from midfield while also ranking among the team’s top interceptors. He carries a direct threat that Hibernian’s midfield will need to account for. On the Hibs side, Jason Kerr has been a rare source of attacking output from defence, netting once and racking up 157 passes in five games, and his ability to drive forward without sacrificing positional discipline gives David Gray’s side a different dimension.
Hot stat from recent form: Hearts scored 13 goals across their last 5 matches compared to Hibernian’s 5. That’s a striking attacking disparity heading into a fixture where both teams are expected to be competitive.
| 🏆 Tournament: | Scottish Premiership 2026/2027 – Regular Season |
| 🏟 Venue: | Easter Road, Edinburgh |
| 🗓️ Date: | 03.09.2026 |
| ⏰ Time: | 20:45 CEST |
Hibernian vs Hearts Prediction
Hearts are the better value pick here, and we think the case for backing them is fairly clear. Wouter Vrancken’s side has been in genuinely impressive form, winning 4 of their last 8 and scoring 13 goals in 5 games. Hibernian, playing at home, will have crowd support, but their attack has been tepid: just 5 goals in the same period. The bookmakers have this almost as a coin flip at roughly 38% Hibs versus 36% Hearts, which seems to undervalue the visitors given the goal output gap.
Stylistically, these teams are worth comparing. Hearts have committed 54 fouls in 5 games and earned only 6 yellow cards, which suggests their aggressive press is disciplined rather than reckless. Hibernian, by contrast, picked up 11 yellow cards from 39 fouls, a ratio that hints at mistimed challenges and reactive defending. In a derby atmosphere at Easter Road, that tendency could lead to trouble, especially against a Hearts side that draws free kicks frequently (77 in 5 matches compared to Hibs’ 29). Hearts’ ball retention is also markedly better: 1,602 passes against Hibernian’s 1,021, with superior accuracy. If they dictate tempo, Hibs will struggle to impose themselves.
| 🔥Hot Tip: | Hearts to score in both halves |
| ⚽Total Goals: | Over 2.5 |
| 💥Both Teams To Score: | Yes |
| 🎯Total Corners: | Over 9.5 |
Team Analysis
Hibernian come into this having won 2 of their 3 Scottish Premiership matches so far, but the European campaign has been mixed. They drew 0-0 with Shkendija and Gent in back-to-back legs, then lost 3-2 to Gent, before bouncing back to beat Dundee 2-1 in their most recent outing. That Dundee win was encouraging, particularly given the squad rotation that has been visible across David Gray’s selections. The concern is the lack of consistent attacking threat: Nathan Lowe, Ante Suto, and Thibault Klidjé have combined for just 1 goal across all five recent matches, and that’s a problem when you’re facing a Hearts side that defends with organisation and punishes on transitions. Felix Passlack has chipped in from midfield and Martin Boyle remains a threat on the flank, but the forward line needs more.
Hearts arrive at Easter Road in strong form. Their last five matches produced a 6-5 thriller against SK Rapid Wien over two legs (winning 6-5 on aggregate), a 6-2 demolition of Inverness, a 1-1 draw with Benfica, and a 2-1 win over Saint Johnstone most recently. That Benfica result alone tells you something about this team’s ambition and quality. Vrancken has a squad that presses high, creates volume in the final third (65 shots in 5 games), and converts at a healthy rate. James Wilson (3 goals), Calvin Miller (3 goals), and Claudio Rafael Soares Braga (1 goal, 1 assist) form a front-line combination that has real depth. Josh McPake’s 2 assists from wide areas add another layer. The only slight concern is the 54 fouls in 5 games, but as noted, the card count has been low, so the referee tolerance seems fine.
🚨Check out our dedicated Hibernian vs Hearts stats page for more info.
The head-to-head record over the last seven meetings is remarkably tight. Hearts have won 4 of those 7 encounters, with Hibernian winning 2 and one draw. The goals tally across those seven games stands at 9 apiece, which tells you this fixture almost always produces both teams scoring. Notably, Hearts have won three of the last four Edinburgh derbies, including a 2-1 win at the 2025/26 Championship playoff stage. Hibernian’s two wins came in the 2024/25 season, both by 2-1, so they are capable of turning it on at home. Honestly though, the recent trajectory favours Hearts.
Pre-game odds and win probability: Hearts the favourite (in value terms)
- Moneyline Hibernian 2.47 | Hearts 2.58
- Draw 3.39
- Over/Under Over 2.5 N/A | Under 2.5 N/A
- BTTS (both teams to score) Yes N/A | No N/A
The market has this remarkably close, with Hibernian’s home advantage pushing them fractionally shorter at most books. But given Hearts’ superior goal output, passing dominance, and the head-to-head trend, the Hearts moneyline around 2.55 looks like a reasonable return for the quality they’ve shown. The draw at 3.39-3.50 is not without appeal either, given how these derbies can tighten up in the second half, but we think Hearts have enough firepower to edge it.
Possible Starting Lineups
Hibernian possible starting eleven
- GK: Raphael Sallinger
- DF: Jason Kerr, Warren O’Hora, Jack Iredale, A. Major
- MF: Josh Mulligan, Jamie McGrath, Felix Passlack, Martin Boyle, Jordan Obita
- FW: Nathan Lowe
David Gray has been fairly consistent with his 4-2-3-1 shape, and this eleven reflects the players who have featured most regularly across the last five matches. Raphael Sallinger starts in goal after being the more active of the two keepers in the data. Jason Kerr anchors the back line and is arguably Hibs’ most complete defender right now, comfortable in possession and willing to step into midfield spaces. The midfield five gives Gray flexibility: Mulligan and McGrath as a double pivot, with Passlack, Boyle, and Obita providing width and creativity ahead of them. Boyle’s pace on the right is the most direct threat Hibs possess. Up front, Lowe has been deployed consistently despite his modest return, and he may need a big performance here to justify his place.
Hearts possible starting eleven
- GK: Beau Reus
- DF: Stuart Findlay, Jamie McCart, Sabah Kerjota, Tom Renaud
- MF: Oisin McEntee, Jordi Altena, Blair Spittal, Christian Dahle Borchgrevink, Calvin Miller
- FW: James Wilson
Vrancken’s 4-2-3-1 has been the settled structure throughout recent fixtures, with Beau Reus commanding in goal (16 saves in 5 games). The back four picks itself: Findlay and McCart as the central pairing have been reliable, with Kerjota and Renaud providing width from the full-back positions. McEntee and Altena form a disciplined double pivot, combining for 397 passes in five games. Spittal and Borchgrevink operate in the half-spaces with real intelligence, while Calvin Miller’s run from deep has been the defining tactical feature of Hearts’ recent play. Wilson leads the line and has 3 goals to show for his efforts. This is a well-balanced eleven with genuine goal threats across multiple positions, which makes them awkward to defend against.
🏅Tips.GG premium subscription brings you even closer to WIN!🏅
- Gain access to the most profitable bets by using our analysis of over 60,000 monthly predictions from 1000+ sources.
- Premium users enjoy predictions from tipsters with the highest win rate while also gaining access to favorable odds, outcome calculation, and quick filter to favorable odds.
- Unlock the “Golden Bet” – our unique formula for the best high-odd betting opportunities! Get detailed reports on our system’s performance, including Winrate, ROI, and Yield.
Hearts. Source: Official Facebook. Edited photo
TipsGG Match Prediction
We think Hearts edge this one. The statistical picture from the last five matches is hard to ignore: 13 goals scored, better passing numbers, more shots, and a disciplined defensive structure that commits fouls without collecting cards. Hibernian at home will fight, and the derby atmosphere at Easter Road does strange things to form guides, but the gap in attacking output between these two sides right now is real. The head-to-head record also leans Hearts’ way, with four wins from seven meetings and three of the last four going in their favour.
Our prediction is Hearts to win, with both teams scoring. Hibs have enough to trouble the visitors, but Hearts’ depth in attack, particularly the Miller-Wilson combination, should prove decisive. Maybe 2-1 or 2-2 if Hibs find a way back into it, but a Hearts win feels like the most grounded outcome here. The “Hearts to score in both halves” hot tip also aligns with how this team has been playing, consistently dangerous from the first whistle rather than sitting back and waiting.
